STR Select evaluated 14 short term rental management companies in Arizona, across 2 markets (Tucson and Sedona), and ranked 10 of them on a printed formula. 3 of the 14 publish a management fee on their own site. Checked October 25, 2026.
One row per market STR Select covers in Arizona. Every count below comes from the 14 Arizona roster records and the fee records that drive the market pages.
| Market | Evaluated | Ranked | Publish a fee | Town guides | Typical full service fee | Updated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tucson Tucson fee index | 5 | 3 | 3 of 5 | 0 | 20 to 25% of revenue | October 21, 2026 |
| Sedona Sedona fee index | 9 | 7 | 0 of 9 | 0 | Only one manager prints a figure, a starting rate of 25% | October 25, 2026 |
A company counts as publishing a fee when its own site prints a rate. A rate reported only by a third party does not count.
Arizona has 2 market pages on STR Select, and Sedona is the largest with 9 evaluated and 7 ranked. All 10 ranked Arizona companies are full service operators. 3 of 14 companies print a fee on their own sites (BnB My Place, 1st Class Vacation Rental Management and Short Term Rentals Tucson), and the fee index holds 11 records marked quote only or not published. 4 companies were evaluated and left unranked: Tucson Vacation Rentals, AZ Realty & Rentals, Halcyon Home Hosting and Red Rock Realty. The typical full service fee recorded per market is 20 to 25% of revenue in Tucson and Only one manager prints a figure, a starting rate of 25% in Sedona. Market by market, Tucson ranks 3 and evaluates 5, with 3 printed fees and Sedona ranks 7 and evaluates 9, with 0 printed fees. Across the 2 markets in Arizona, the ranked share is 71 percent, with 10 ranked rows against 4 evaluated without a rank. 0 of the 10 ranked companies in Arizona are marked as a featured placement, because rank here follows the printed formula and nothing else. The ranked Arizona records cite 19 distinct source pages across 11 domains for their service areas and fees. On the printed formula, the first ranked row in Tucson is BnB My Place and Sedona is Folsom Management. Among the 10 ranked companies, 2 state a rating and 10 state a portfolio size on their own sites; the rest leave both out. The ranked companies’ fee fields were checked in October 2026 and 2026-10-25. The Arizona market pages carry 2 different updated dates, from October 21, 2026 to October 25, 2026. The 10 ranked companies are based in 2 places: Tucson, Arizona and Sedona, Arizona. No company prints a fee on its own site in Sedona. A fee printed on a company’s own site appears in Tucson. The ranked companies that state a portfolio size are BnB My Place, Short Term Rentals Tucson, 1st Class Vacation Rental Management, Folsom Management, Porter, SkyRun Vacation Rentals Sedona, VacayAZ, Foothills Property Management, Sedona Premier and Sedona.org. The ranked companies that state a rating are BnB My Place and Short Term Rentals Tucson. Ranks in this state run from #1 to #7, and each rank is local to its market table, not a statewide order.
4 companies were evaluated in Arizona and left outside the ranked tier.
Of the 14 Arizona companies in our roster, 10 are ranked and 4 are evaluated and not ranked. Tucson ranks 3 and lists 2 more; Sedona ranks 7 and lists 2 more. In Arizona, not ranked means a company sits outside the printed top tier of its own market table. It is not a judgment on the company, and each of the 4 keeps its own profile page.
Listed alphabetically, with the market it was evaluated in. Each name opens its profile.
| Company | Market | Status | Fee on its own site |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st Class Vacation Rental Management | Tucson | Ranked | 20% flat fee on the nightly rental rate only; cleaning, pet and other guest fees are never shared with the company |
| AZ Realty & Rentals | Tucson | Evaluated, not ranked | Not published |
| BnB My Place | Tucson | Ranked | 20% of net rental proceeds |
| Folsom Management | Sedona | Ranked | Not published |
| Foothills Property Management | Sedona | Ranked | Not published |
| Halcyon Home Hosting | Sedona | Evaluated, not ranked | Not published |
| Porter | Sedona | Ranked | Not published |
| Red Rock Realty | Sedona | Evaluated, not ranked | Not published |
| Sedona Premier | Sedona | Ranked | Not published |
| Sedona.org | Sedona | Ranked | Not published |
| Short Term Rentals Tucson | Tucson | Ranked | 20 to 25% commission; 20% for owners who list multiple properties |
| SkyRun Vacation Rentals Sedona | Sedona | Ranked | Not published |
| Tucson Vacation Rentals | Tucson | Evaluated, not ranked | Not published |
| VacayAZ | Sedona | Ranked | Not published |
3 rates from 3 companies, each read on the company's own site and dated.
| Company | Market | Model | Published rate | Checked | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BnB My Place | Tucson | Full service | 20% of net rental proceeds | Oct 9 2026 | bnbmyplace.com |
| 1st Class Vacation Rental Management | Tucson | Full service | 20% flat fee on the nightly rental rate only; cleaning, pet and other guest fees are never shared with the company | Oct 9 2026 | tucsonbnbmanagement.com |
| Short Term Rentals Tucson | Tucson | Full service | 20 to 25% commission; 20% for owners who list multiple properties | Oct 9 2026 | shorttermrentalstucson.com |
Read straight from the ranked tier of each market, with no company singled out.
Tucson has 5 evaluated companies in the Arizona roster. The 3 ranked ones split into 3 full service. 3 of the 5 print a rate on their own site (BnB My Place, 1st Class Vacation Rental Management and Short Term Rentals Tucson). The ranked companies work from one base: Tucson, Arizona.
Tucson has no separate town guides yet, so every Arizona owner question for this market is answered on the market page. 2 national brands with a dedicated Tucson page on their own site are noted but not ranked against the local companies: Awning and Casago.
Sedona has 9 evaluated companies in the Arizona roster. The 7 ranked ones split into 7 full service. None of the 9 evaluated in Sedona prints a rate on its own site, so the only one manager prints a figure, a starting rate of 25% note on the Sedona market page is the best record we hold. The ranked companies work from one base: Sedona, Arizona.
Sedona has no separate town guides yet, so every Arizona owner question for this market is answered on the market page. 3 national brands with a dedicated Sedona page on their own site are noted but not ranked against the local companies: Casago, AvantStay and Mighty Tree Properties.
Answered from the same sourced research behind the rankings.
14 companies across 2 markets: 5 in Tucson, 9 in Sedona. 10 are ranked and 4 are evaluated and not ranked.
3 of 14: BnB My Place, 1st Class Vacation Rental Management and Short Term Rentals Tucson. The other 11 quote privately or print no rate on the pages we read. Each rate carries its source and checked date in the fee table on this page.
Tucson (3 companies ranked of 5 evaluated) and Sedona (7 companies ranked of 9 evaluated). There is no town guide in this state yet.
Tucson: 20 to 25% of revenue; Sedona: Only one manager prints a figure, a starting rate of 25%. These are the ranges recorded on the Arizona market pages, not a quote from any single Arizona company.
By one printed formula that scores each market table on its own. Arizona has 10 ranked companies across 2 markets, and fee transparency is the heaviest input at 30% of a score. Nobody pays for a rank in Arizona or anywhere else. The full method is printed on the methodology page.
The newest Arizona market page was updated October 25, 2026. Each of the 2 market pages in Arizona prints its own updated date, and every fee carries the date we read it.
Every outbound link below is already used on the Arizona market pages: 14 company sites, 14 fee index records and the national brand evidence pages.
Transparency: STR Select has no paid placements. Corrections: companies can claim their listing to correct anything on their profile.