STR Select’s Smoky Mountains fee index tracks 16 cabin managers, and two of them publish a rate: Cabins For You and Short Term Coops. The other 14 quote privately.
Two of the 16 cabin management companies in our Smoky Mountains fee index publish a rate. Here is what those two companies charge, and what the other 14 are not saying.
Only 2 of the 16 Smoky Mountains managers in our fee index publish a rate on their own site, and we rechecked both live on Sept 26 2026. Cabins For You charges 10% management fee, and Short Term Coops charges Flat 20% of net rental revenue plus a $75 monthly technology fee. The other 14 quote privately.
Quote-only pricing lets a manager price each cabin separately by size, amenities and location rather than commit to one public number. That is the model 14 of the 16 companies in our Smoky Mountains index use. We keep the full record, including who has and has not published, in the Smoky Mountains fee index, with the date we checked each company's own pricing page.
Cabins For You, based in Gatlinburg, publishes a flat 10% management fee on its own site, rechecked Sept 26 2026. Short Term Coops, an in-house manager in the Pigeon Forge area, structures its rate differently: Flat 20% of net rental revenue plus a $75 monthly technology fee.
| Company | Model | Published Rate | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cabins For You | Full service | 10% management fee | Sept 26 2026 |
| Short Term Coops | Full service, in-house | Flat 20% of net rental revenue plus a $75 monthly technology fee | Sept 26 2026 |
Both rows quote each company's own published wording. See every other company's fee status, published or not, in the Smoky Mountains fee index.
The two published rates use different structures on purpose. A flat percentage like Cabins For You's is easier to project against revenue, while Short Term Coops' flat rate plus a separate monthly technology fee means the all-in cost moves differently as a cabin's revenue changes month to month.
A worked example shows how far apart the two structures sit. Take a cabin that books $60,000 in a year, and assume for the example that the whole amount counts as net rental revenue, since neither company’s page defines a deduction we can price. Cabins For You at 10% comes to $6,000. Short Term Coops at a flat 20% comes to $12,000, and its $75 monthly technology fee adds $900 over twelve months, for $12,900 in total. The gap is $6,900, or 11.5% of the revenue.
Treat that as arithmetic on two printed rates, not a forecast. Neither page states what the percentage excludes, what each company books for a cabin like yours, or whether other charges apply, and any of those can move the net result by more than the headline gap. Use the example to frame the question you put to each quote-only manager: what is the percentage charged on, and what sits outside it.
Published rates we found across the Smoky Mountains range from 10% management fee to a flat 20% of net revenue, with most companies declining to publish at all. That spread is wider than the tighter band we found in the Poconos, which makes the two published Smoky Mountains numbers a useful anchor precisely because so few others disclose one. Our full management fee guide covers how fee ranges hold across markets nationally, and the fee calculator applies both published Smoky Mountains rates to your own revenue number.
The Smoky Mountains index records two published rates. The other market indexes on this site record a wider spread, and every row below carries the date we checked it. The Poconos fee index records Galvanized Management at 25% of net rent (checked Oct 28 2026) and Pocono Pads at 12% of gross revenue plus $1,000 one time signing fee (checked Sept 28 2026). The Broken Bow fee index records The Bear Cabins at 20% commission on rent for full service; 15% for its co-hosting tier (checked Oct 19 2026). BnB My Place is recorded on the Tucson fee index at 20% of net rental proceeds (checked Oct 9 2026). Destination Big Bear is recorded on the Big Bear Lake fee index at 27% management fee; the owner FAQ answers “What is your management fee?” with “27%” (checked Oct 24 2026). XENO Management is recorded on the Orlando fee index at 15% of rental revenue in Greater Orlando; Remote Management 10% of rental revenue, nationwide; VIP pricing on request (checked Oct 29 2026).
Read side by side, those rows show how far the published percentages sit apart: 10% at Cabins For You and 27% at Destination Big Bear, with 12%, 15%, 20% and 25% rows in between. Most of the rows sit between 15% and 25%, which is the band an owner should plan to negotiate inside even when a local manager will not print a number. The structure matters as much as the percentage: a flat 20% plus a $75 monthly technology fee is not the same offer as a 12% rate with a $1,000 signing fee, because the two arrangements place their extra cost at different points in the year.
None of those rows says what a cabin in Gatlinburg will cost. What they do is bound the question. When a quote-only Smoky Mountains manager names a rate, the published rows above tell you whether that number sits inside the range other managers print or outside it, and whether a separate fee is likely to arrive on top.
A management fee is not the only published number an owner should read before signing. The Smoky Mountains registration record checks each city’s own permit page, and every row carries the date we checked it. Gatlinburg prints the most complete figure: $200 for a unit with two or fewer bedrooms, plus $75 for each additional bedroom. Covers the fire and building inspection. That row was checked 2026-10-08, and the record links the city’s own permit page.
Sevierville requires a Short Term Rental Operational Permit and renews it annually, but the city’s own page does not print the amount. The record therefore leaves the dollar figure unstated rather than borrowing one from a third party summary, and names the application guide where the city sets it. Pigeon Forge has no short term rental permit program published on its own forms and permits page as of the check, so an owner there should confirm the current rule with the city before filing anything.
Use the two published rates as your reference point before you get on a call with a quote-only manager.
Fee transparency is the largest single input in our ranking formula because it is the one input a company fully controls and still withholds most often. We weight it at 30%, ahead of verified reviews at 25%, local depth at 25% and service scope at 20%. A company that publishes its rate scores higher on this input regardless of what the number is, because the question this input answers is whether a buyer can learn the price before a sales call, not whether the price is low. The full formula is printed on our methodology page.
The fee index behind this post lists one row per company and model, each read from the company’s own site. By status, 13 quote only and 2 published. By model, 13 full service, 1 full service, in-house and 1 full service, all-inclusive.
| Company | Model | Status | Rate on the company’s page | Source | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cabins For You | Full service | Published | 10% management fee | cabinsforyou.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Short Term Coops | Full service, in-house | Published | Flat 20% of net rental revenue plus a $75 monthly technology fee | shorttermcoops.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Elk Springs Resort | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | elkspringsresort.com | Oct 5 2026 |
| Compass Vacation Properties | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | compassvacationproperties.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Cabins of the Smoky Mountains | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | cabinsofthesmokymountains.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Fireside Chalets | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | firesidechalets.com | Oct 5 2026 |
| Eden Crest Vacation Rentals | Full service, all-inclusive | Quote only | No rate printed | edencrest.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Bear Camp Cabin Rentals | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | bearcampcabins.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Bear Tootin' Cabin Rentals | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | beartootin.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Auntie Belham's Cabin Rentals | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | auntiebelhams.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Hearthside Cabin Rentals | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | hearthsidecabinrentals.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Parkside Cabin Rentals | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | parksidecabinrentals.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Chalet Village | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | chaletvillage.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| VTrips | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | vtrips.com | Sept 26 2026 |
| Vacasa | Full service | Quote only | No rate printed | vacasa.com | Sept 26 2026 |
Dates are the day each company’s own page was last read. The index itself carries the label September 2026.
Some quote-only rows still carry a fact worth knowing before a first call.
The index summarizes the market this way: 2 of 16 managers evaluated publish a rate, and its range note reads “Most companies quote privately; published rates found range from 10% to a flat 20% of net revenue”. The published wording is Cabins For You at “10% management fee” and Short Term Coops at “Flat 20% of net rental revenue plus a $75 monthly technology fee”.
Grouped by the day each page was read, Sept 26 2026 covers Cabins For You, Short Term Coops, Compass Vacation Properties, Cabins of the Smoky Mountains, Eden Crest Vacation Rentals, Bear Camp Cabin Rentals, Bear Tootin' Cabin Rentals, Auntie Belham's Cabin Rentals, Hearthside Cabin Rentals, Parkside Cabin Rentals, Chalet Village, VTrips and Vacasa and Oct 5 2026 covers Elk Springs Resort and Fireside Chalets.
The 15 source domains read for this table are cabinsforyou.com, shorttermcoops.com, elkspringsresort.com, compassvacationproperties.com, cabinsofthesmokymountains.com, firesidechalets.com, edencrest.com, bearcampcabins.com, beartootin.com, auntiebelhams.com, hearthsidecabinrentals.com, parksidecabinrentals.com, chaletvillage.com, vtrips.com and vacasa.com. The rows carry 2 different checked dates: Sept 26 2026 and Oct 5 2026.
Answered from the fee index, not a general range.
No. A cabin generating more bookings at a higher fee can out-earn a cheaper manager who books fewer nights. Compare projected net income across quotes, not just the percentage or flat fee.
Ask for the number in writing before any walkthrough. 14 of the 16 companies in our Smoky Mountains index do not publish a rate, so plan to evaluate quote-only managers on review history, local staffing and service scope instead.
Cabins For You charges a straightforward 10% management fee. Short Term Coops charges a flat 20% of net rental revenue plus a separate $75 monthly technology fee, a different structure that bundles a software cost into the arrangement rather than folding it into the percentage.
The full scored list, including the 14 companies that do not publish a rate, is at our Smoky Mountains ranking, and every rate we could find is in the fee index.
Tell us about the property once. We offer it to one well reviewed local manager at a time, and your contact details go only to the one that accepts.
Part of STR Select. About us, report a correction, image and data credits, privacy.
This page cites no outside pages. It is built from these STR Select data pages and files: